Article Navigation
Article Contents
-
Funding
-
Competing interests
-
Data availability
-
References
- < Previous
- Next >
Journal Article
, Sam Olum Department of Internal Medicine, Gulu Medical School, Gulu University , Gulu , Uganda St Mary’s Hospital, Lacor , Gulu , Uganda Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Charlotte Scolding Department of Internal Medicine, Gulu Medical School, Gulu University , Gulu , Uganda St Mary’s Hospital, Lacor , Gulu , Uganda Translational Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Bristol , Bristol BS10 5NB , UK Emergency Medicine Department, Royal United Hospital , Bath BA1 3NG , UK Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Venice Omona Department of Internal Medicine, Gulu Medical School, Gulu University , Gulu , Uganda St Mary’s Hospital, Lacor , Gulu , Uganda Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Kansiime Jackson Department of Internal Medicine, Gulu Medical School, Gulu University , Gulu , Uganda St Mary’s Hospital, Lacor , Gulu , Uganda Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Neil Scolding Department of Internal Medicine, Gulu Medical School, Gulu University , Gulu , Uganda St Mary’s Hospital, Lacor , Gulu , Uganda Translational Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Bristol , Bristol BS10 5NB , UK Department of Neurology, Gloucestershire Hospitals NHS Trust , Cheltenham GL53 7AN , UK Correspondence to: Neil Scolding St Mary’s Hospital, Lacor, Gulu, Uganda E-mail: n.j.scolding@bristol.ac.uk Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic
Brain Communications, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2024, fcae168, https://doi.org/10.1093/braincomms/fcae168
Published:
10 May 2024
Article history
Received:
25 March 2024
Revision received:
25 March 2024
Accepted:
09 May 2024
Published:
10 May 2024
Corrected and typeset:
18 July 2024
- Split View
- Views
- Article contents
- Figures & tables
- Video
- Audio
- Supplementary Data
-
Cite
Cite
Sam Olum, Charlotte Scolding, Venice Omona, Kansiime Jackson, Neil Scolding, Response to: ‘Acute flaccid myelitis in low to middle income countries: diagnosis and surveillance’, Brain Communications, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2024, fcae168, https://doi.org/10.1093/braincomms/fcae168
Close
Search
Close
Search
Advanced Search
Search Menu
We are grateful to Helfferich and colleagues1 for their interest in our work2 and for their thoughtful and insightful comments. We particularly agree that two questions concerning acute flaccid myelitis (AFM)—sensory loss and diagnostic criteria—are of especial interest.
Regarding sensory deficits, we agree (and ourselves indicated2) that the finding of a sensory level and painless burns in one of our reported cases does under the current criteria3 cast doubt on the AFM diagnosis (notwithstanding the difficulty in imagining an alternative cause for the clinical picture, with such persistent flaccidity).
Current diagnostic criteria3 do not stipulate that sensory loss absolutely excludes AFM; rather, they stress that sensory deficits ‘might suggest an alternative diagnosis’ while adding that ‘at present, there are no data describing the frequency of [sensory] features in patients with AFM’.3
It may be prudent, however, to retain some flexibility on the point, several studies suggesting that sensory changes are in fact not uncommon. Messacar et al.4 report US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention surveillance documenting sensory involvement in 21% of cases, while Van Haren et al.5 record sensory loss in 26/59 (44%) of AFM patients—‘10 had deficits in both pain/temperature and fine touch/vibration, and …[a] sensory level was specified or implied in 6 patients’.
Helfferich et al.1 reasonably make the point that AFM is mainly an anterior horn disease, so that sensory loss would not be expected. However, it may be valuable to rehearse a comparable discussion from some 70 years ago concerning the archetypical AFM, poliomyelitis. Both James Waldo Lance and Fred Plum, among others, reported significant sensory loss in a small minority of poliomyelitis patients, with a clear sensory level in some.6-9 Histopathological studies provided a compelling explanation, namely that the extensive nerve cell destruction in the spinal cord grey matter in some cases was associated with a severe inflammatory reaction often extending to the sensory pathways (particularly the dorsal columns).9,10 Rather later, detailed neurophysiological studies of polio patients also confirmed the presence of sensory abnormalities.11 It is not difficult to imagine similar changes in current cases of AFM.
The poliomyelitis literature is also of interest in indicating the occasional occurrence of second attacks of polio,12-14 an atypical feature again suggested historically in two of our cases.
Concerning diagnostic criteria, Helfferich and colleagues1 helpfully suggest pragmatic features appropriate to resource-limited settings that might support a clinical diagnosis of AFM, recognizing that ‘in clinical practice, a certain level of uncertainty is not uncommon’. They rightly emphasize, however, that for scientific studies, ranging from exploration of pathogenesis to the ascertainment of incidence and prevalence, it is vital to retain the highest possible levels of diagnostic rigour—which, they aver, must include MRI scanning. They agree, however, that this then excludes much of the resource-limited world.
Perhaps remembering poliomyelitis might be useful here also. A secure diagnosis hardly depended on imaging; rather, clinical features together with, importantly, virological results were more than sufficient. As Helfferich et al.1 mention, the World Health Organization has established a network of viral laboratories to conduct surveillance for detecting poliomyelitis re-emergence. One such, the Uganda Virus Research Institute, is based in Entebbe. We have recently gained research funding to conduct viral studies, looking for enteroviruses, arboviruses and other viruses previously associated with flaccid paralysis syndromes, in patients with AFM in four different hospitals across Uganda (with MRI scanning in two). Serum, stool and CSF samples and nasopharyngeal swabs can of course be stored cold for delayed testing after transport. Incorporating viral results into the AFM diagnostic criteria in place of MRI scanning—or perhaps better, as an ‘either/or’—might offer the prospect of presenting AFM criteria that are inclusive of resource-limited settings. Confirmation of the diagnosis would be slower, but in the absence of any useful treatment, this is arguably no major disadvantage. We would very much welcome further dialogue and collaboration with AFM authorities in the global north to explore further this important neurological disease.
Funding
Our AFM research funding is provided by Ferblanc and by the Guarantors of Brain.
Competing interests
The authors report no competing interests.
Data availability
Data sharing is not applicable to this article as no new data were created or analysed.
References
1
Helfferich J Fall A Pardo CA Jacobs BC Messacar K
Acute flaccid myelitis in low to middle income countries: Diagnosis and surveillance
.
Brain Commun
.
2024
;
6
.
OpenURL Placeholder Text
2
Olum S Scolding C Omona V Jackson K Scolding N
Acute flaccid myelitis: Not uncommon in rural Uganda?
Brain Commun
.
2023
;
5
:
fcad246
.
3
Murphy OC Messacar K Benson L
Acute flaccid myelitis: Cause, diagnosis, and management
.
Lancet
.
2021
;
397
:
334
–
346
.
4
Messacar K Schreiner TL Van Haren K
Acute flaccid myelitis: A clinical review of US cases 2012–2015
.
Ann Neurol
.
2016
;
80
:
326
–
338
.
5
Van Haren K Ayscue P Waubant E
Acute flaccid myelitis of unknown etiology in California, 2012–2015
.
JAMA
.
2015
;
314
:
2663
–
2671
.
6
Sandifer PH
Poliomyelitis with sensory signs
.
Proc R Soc Med
.
1950
;
43
:
950
.
7
Plum F
Sensory loss with poliomyelitis
.
Neurology
.
1956
;
6
:
166
–
172
.
8
Walley RV
Sensory loss in poliomyelitis
.
Br Med J
.
1961
;
2
:
33
.
9
Lance JW White SW Dodgson MC
Sensory loss in poliomyelitis
.
Australas Ann Med
.
1963
;
12
:
221
–
229
.
10
Bodian D
Histopathologic basis of clinical findings in poliomyelitis
.
Am J Med
.
1949
;
6
:
563
–
578
.
11
Prokhorenko OA Vasconcelos OM Lupu VD Campbell WW Jabbari B
Sensory physiology assessed by evoked potentials in survivors of poliomyelitis
.
Muscle Nerve
.
2008
;
38
:
1266
–
1271
.
12
Faro SN
Recurrent paralytic poliomyelitis; report of a case, documented with virus isolations
.
N Engl J Med
.
1959
;
260
:
1177
–
1178
.
13
Bodian D
Second attacks of paralytic poliomyelitis in human beings in relation to immunity, virus types and virulence, with a report of two cases, and four other individuals in Baltimore, 1944, infected with virus of the Leon type
.
Am J Hyg
.
1951
;
54
:
174
–
190
.
14
Fox MJ
Recurrent poliomyelitis
.
Lancet
.
1952
;
2
:
882
–
883
.
© The Author(s) 2024. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Guarantors of Brain.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Issue Section:
Letter to the Editor
Download all slides
Advertisem*nt intended for healthcare professionals
Citations
Views
16
Altmetric
More metrics information
Metrics
Total Views 16
0 Pageviews
16 PDF Downloads
Since 5/1/2024
Month: | Total Views: |
---|---|
May 2024 | 13 |
June 2024 | 2 |
July 2024 | 1 |
Citations
Powered by Dimensions
Altmetrics
Email alerts
Article activity alert
Advance article alerts
New issue alert
In progress issue alert
Receive exclusive offers and updates from Oxford Academic
See also
-
Commentary
- Acute flaccid myelitis in low- to middle-income countries: diagnosis and surveillance
Citing articles via
Google Scholar
-
Latest
-
Most Read
-
Most Cited
More from Oxford Academic
Medicine and Health
Neurology
Neuroscience
Science and Mathematics
Books
Journals
Advertisem*nt intended for healthcare professionals